Technical Symposium on Computer Science Education

March 12-15, 2008 • Portland, Oregon, USA

Guidelines for Reviewers


Here are some recommendations for writing reviews that help the authors and improve the quality of the symposium. 


Examples of Good Reviews

Below are examples of comments that have been found in good, useful reviews:


The paper presentation (organization and writing style) 

The idea or work presented is original and appropriately builds on and acknowledges previous work in the area

The paper is technically sound; it includes evidence for any statements or conclusions that it makes

The idea or work presented has potential to contribute to CS education

Overall evaluation